スレッド立てるまでもない質問スレッド part272

このエントリーをはてなブックマークに追加
841名無しさん@英語勉強中
One of the in relative clauses: singular or plural verb?

Q: My students and I have been working out subject-verb agreement in relative clauses.

We have discussed the following sentences:

S1: One of the students who are American was late.

S2: Only one of the students who is American was late.

In S1, the adjective clause refers to "students" ― verb is plural.
In S2, the adjective clause refers to "one" ― verb is singular.

Is it possible to write:

S3: One of the students who is American was late.

I want to show that only one student is American and that this student was late.


さて、回答や如何に?